A Seoul court has dismissed a major damages claim against a K-pop idol, ruling that a private encounter could not be grounds for contract termination.
The case involved an unnamed member of a four-member boy group, referred to as “A,” who debuted at the relatively late age of 28 after a failed first debut attempt. On January 8, 2023, A met a woman through friends during a night out and they spent the night together.
Just a week later, his agency presented him with a “debt memorandum” demanding that he take responsibility for any losses linked to the alleged scandal. The terms included covering all album production and promotion costs, contractual penalties, and even a clause allowing the agency to claim payment from his family if he couldn’t pay.
Hoping to remain in the group, A signed the document — only to be removed from the group and have his contract terminated two days later. The agency then sued him for ₩200 million KRW (approx. $145,000 USD), citing a violation of his “duty to maintain dignity” as an idol.
However, the Seoul Central District Court ruled that the consensual act did not constitute a criminal offense, nor did it become public through media coverage, meaning it could not be considered a breach of contract. The court also voided the debt memorandum, labeling it an “unfair legal act” under Korean law.
The judge noted that A’s circumstances — older than most idols and desperate for his second chance — left him vulnerable to exploitation by the agency. The lawsuit was dismissed in full, with the agency ordered to cover all legal costs.
Sources: Law Talk News
You must be logged in to post a comment.