This controversy has sparked debate, with some arguing that selling gifts constitutes deception, while others believe that since the gifts became his property, selling them is not deceitful.
On Jan 29th, screenshots of a conversation between a fan and a member of a boy group surfaced on an online community. The uploaded post contains the contents of the idol group member discussing reselling gifts received from fans.
In the product description, it is stated, “I bought it by myself in Japan with 270,000-280,000 won this autumn. After washing it once, the printing faded a little so I don’t wear it anymore. I’m selling it at a cheaper price.” The controversy started when the fan who had given the gift to the idol group member saw the post.
The fan attempted to talk directly to the seller, who apologized, “I’m sorry. I wasn’t thinking straight. I had many concerns because it was the end of the year. During times like that, I often buy things I want to solve my worries. However, I couldn’t ask my parents for money, that’s why I couldn’t think straight and acted recklessly. I’m really sorry.”
The protagonist of this controversy has been confirmed to be Jang Yubin of DSP Media’s boy group MIRAE. Jang Yubin is deeply reflecting on the act of reselling gifts received from fans.
There is ongoing debate about whether Jang Yubin’s behavior constitutes fan deception. Some argue that deception goes beyond mere deceit and includes attitudes of underestimating and disregarding the other party.
While the selling behavior may be inappropriate, it cannot be seen as an attempt by Jang Yubin to deceive or underestimate others. In the industry, actions such as giving gifts received from fans to romantic partners or using the initials of lovers in conversations with fans have been criticized as “fan deception”. Some also view this incident as symbolic of idols’ hardships of life.
MIRAE is causing issues beyond their albums. In 2022, member Yoo Dohyun received backlash for parodying the choreography expressions of Billlie’s Tsuki. Personal actions of members are negatively impacting the group as a whole. This controversy also leaves a sense of disappointment regarding Jang Yubin’s lack of thoughts and actions.
Source: Daum
