The FIFA Club World Cup 2025 semifinal between Chelsea and Fluminense was rocked by controversy after a crucial VAR decision in the first half.
In the 35th minute, with Chelsea leading 1-0, Fluminense earned a free-kick from the left flank. The ball was lofted into the box, and Trevoh Chalobah appeared to handle it inside his own penalty area. Referee Francois Letexier immediately pointed to the spot, awarding a penalty to the Brazilian side.
However, the drama escalated as VAR intervened. After a lengthy review, Letexier reversed his original decision, ruling no penalty—despite the handball being clearly visible on replay and Chalobah making no apparent effort to keep his arm close to his body.
The decision sparked fierce protests from Fluminense players, who argued that the incident should have resulted in a spot-kick. Had the penalty stood, it could have changed the course of the match, possibly preventing Fluminense’s eventual bitter defeat.
The incident has reignited debates over the consistency of VAR interpretations, particularly in handball situations. Many fans and analysts questioned the overturn, calling it another example of VAR “overruling clear infractions.”
As discussions continue, this moment is likely to remain a flashpoint in the tournament’s legacy.