On November 12, global headlines confirmed: Sabrina Carpenter, the pop sensation behind the hit “Espresso,” will star and co-produce a new musical inspired by Lewis Carroll’s iconic tale, Alice in Wonderland.

Backed by Universal Pictures, this yet-untitled project also brings in Marc Platt the powerhouse producer behind Wicked fueling anticipation for a grand-scale musical experience. While Alice has seen multiple incarnations, this upcoming adaptation promises a modern twist.

Although Carpenter’s specific role has yet to be confirmed, news of her portraying Alice has ignited fiery debate online. On one hand, fans praise her “candy-sweet looks,” golden curls, and fairytale aura as fitting for the role. On the other hand, critics argue her consistently sensual public image from daring stage outfits to sultry performances clashes with the original portrayal of Alice as an innocent, pure girl.

I like her, but Alice is supposed to be around 10 years old. I just can’t picture Sabrina pulling off that innocent vibe,” a netizen commented. Others echoed the sentiment, suggesting a rising young actress would suit the role better.

What intrigues the public even more is that Carpenter reportedly spearheaded the project developing the concept, assembling a lookbook, and pitching it to Universal. This positions her not just as an actress, but a creative force shaping the project’s vision.

Despite standing at just 151 cm, Sabrina Carpenter has earned praise as a multi-talented performer, known for Girl Meets World, Tall Girl, Clouds, and Emergency. She’s also become a fashion icon, admired for her confident, bold style traits that could either redefine Alice or derail the adaptation in fans’ eyes.

So, the big question lingers: Can Sabrina Carpenter tone down the glam and channel the purity of Lewis Carroll’s beloved Alice? Or are we in for a radically reimagined, grown-up Alice that flips the script entirely?

Public reactions range from excitement to intense skepticism:

  • “This sounds interesting, but Alice is such a sacred Disney icon most studios are afraid to touch it.”
  • “Sexualizing a childhood character like Alice is just wrong.”
  • “I love Sabrina, but she’s too mature-looking for this role.”
  • “Are we getting a quirky retelling or something faithful to the original?”
  • “Please dress appropriately! Alice shouldn’t look like a pin-up.”
  • “I’ve never seen a sexy Alice before… until now.”
  • “This whole vibe feels off. She’s too old for Alice!”
  • “A fiery Alice? Nah, this ain’t it.”

Sources: K14