Alvaro Carreras
Despite not making a single first-team appearance for United, Carreras was sold to Benfica for just £5 million. Surprisingly, Real Madrid later paid £43 million for the 22-year-old left-back. Carreras is now seen as proof that “Manchester United doesn’t know how to use its talent” — and sometimes, leaving is the real beginning.
Scott McTominay
McTominay scored 29 goals in 255 games for United but struggled to cement his place. After moving to Napoli, he flourished under Antonio Conte, netting 13 goals in his debut season, helping the club win Serie A, and earning Player of the Season honors. Locals now call him “Maradona’s heir” — an unthinkable title during his time at Old Trafford.
Anthony Elanga
Previously seen as a backup winger with raw pace but little end product, Elanga has reinvented himself at Nottingham Forest. His standout performances led the club to its first European qualification in over 30 years. Newcastle even offered £60 million for him — a stunning rise for a once-overlooked talent.
Dean Henderson
Overshadowed at United and sidelined by COVID-19, Henderson resurrected his career at Crystal Palace. In the 2024/25 season, he played 44 games and was key to their historic FA Cup win, including a crucial penalty save against Man City in the final. Now back in the England squad, he’s among the most reliable goalkeepers in the country.
Angel Di Maria
Di Maria’s stint at United lasted only one disappointing season, but his post-Old Trafford career proved legendary. He went on to play nearly 300 games for PSG, winning five Ligue 1 titles, and starred at Juventus and Benfica. His crowning moment came with Argentina’s 2022 World Cup victory. United was merely a blip in his journey to greatness.
Fred
Often underrated at United, Fred found new appreciation after joining Fenerbahce in 2023. Under José Mourinho, the Brazilian midfielder became a cornerstone of a side battling Galatasaray for the Turkish title. While United still struggles in midfield, Fred has flourished in Istanbul.
Antony
Signed for £86 million, Antony underwhelmed at United. However, after being loaned to Real Betis, he scored 5 goals and provided 2 assists, helping the Spanish club qualify for the Europa League and reach the Conference League final. Betis is now negotiating a permanent deal for just £17 million — a bargain compared to his original price tag.