The controversy ignited when a TikTok influencer shared a now-viral video dissecting the audio components of “Gnarly.” Citing rumors about one of the sounds used, the creator reached out to the song’s producer, who then revealed behind-the-scenes details that shocked viewers.
The focal point of the backlash is a particular sound embedded in the track — one that, when isolated, resembles a woman moaning, evoking sexual connotations. The producer admitted the sound was added because the song needed “something extra,” and cryptically encouraged viewers to “take a guess” as to its origin after playing the unedited audio clip.
The controversy intensified when Pink Slip, one of the co-writers, reacted positively to comments about the moaning audio. In a social media post, when someone remarked, “I can’t believe you added this in,” he replied, “Without it, this wouldn’t be a hit.” This statement has been widely condemned online as tone-deaf and exploitative.
Even the influencer, initially curious, appeared visibly uncomfortable upon hearing the full sound, underscoring the disturbing nature of the implication. Once the clip went viral, netizens were quick to express outrage, particularly in light of the fact that KATSEYE features underage members. The notion of sexual sound effects being used in a group involving minors — and performed at family-friendly events like the Kids’ Choice Awards — has been labeled by many as deeply inappropriate and “disturbing.”
Online reactions were swift and damning, with users condemning the production team for what they described as a “failure in judgment” and “utterly tone-deaf” handling of sensitive content. Critics emphasized that even if the original source of the sound wasn’t explicitly confirmed, the producer’s coy remark and the audio itself were enough to trigger concern, especially in the context of an idol group aimed at younger audiences.
Critics point to the presence of minor member Yoonchae (Jeong Yoon-chae, age 17) in KATSEYE, saying that such content is especially inappropriate in a group that includes underage idols. This has led to calls for accountability from Bang Si-hyuk, who is not only credited as co-composer but also serves as HYBE’s executive chairman.
One industry insider commented,“Given the production process, it’s difficult to believe the final version wasn’t approved intentionally. As a listed producer, Bang Si-hyuk would have been aware of the content.”
This incident has reignited conversations about the responsibility of producers and entertainment companies when creating content for groups with minor performers. Fans and watchdogs alike are now demanding accountability — and more stringent ethical guidelines — in the music industry.
Sources: koreaboo
You must be logged in to post a comment.